Apart from their starkly different origins, how different are Karate and boxing?
Can training in one form prepare you for the other?
Is one better than the other in a potential self-defense scenario? What about general fitness, agility and skills?
Most people looking to learn a self-defense technique or a martial art purely for fitness, are torn between selecting something traditional like Karate or a little bit modern, like boxing.
Parents looking to enroll their kids in training schools, frequently face the same conundrum.
This blog post aims to put it to rest once and for all by pointing out the key differences in boxing and karate.
What is Karate?
Karate is a Japanese martial art with oriental (possibly feudal) origins that relies on unarmed combat with punches and kicks. The onus is as much on fighting and self-defense, as it is on physical fitness and mental co-ordination.
While it originated in Okinawa in ancient Japan, it has travelled around the world and today is widely practiced in the United States.
Modern day karate is a more refined version of the full-contact form that was practiced earlier though, with an emphasis on practicing it as a gentler, combat sport.
To the untrained eye, Karate or any other martial art for that matter might look like a simple sequence of blocks and counter offensive moves.
But in reality, ancient Karatekas have mastered and incorporated the laws of physics into Karate, which explains why skilled practitioners are able to defy physical strength by channeling all their energy into seemingly simple moves.
What is Boxing?
Boxing is a combat sport where two opponents fight with fists. That’s the simplest way to define it.
While ancient fist fighting has been around for centuries, modern day boxing evolved somewhere in the 18th century and has traces of Wrestling as well.
Boxing matches take place in an enclosed, square area called ‘The Ring’ and consists of multiple timed-rounds which will be determined by judges who sit outside.
A referee oversees the match inside of the ring.
Boxing Vs Karate – What Are The Differences?
There are several key differences in the two.
- Karate has a whole expanse of techniques that you can master. And often, it takes years to master all of them. However, more the number of techniques there are to learn, less the time you spend learning each one of them. In Karate, there is a definite emphasis on applying the skills you learn for self-defense. Many sparring sessions aim to simulate a self-defense scenario.
- Boxing on the other hand has very few techniques to master since it solely involves punches and evasive moves. The caveat is that you have ample time to master each one of these moves. You can work for months and years on your uppercuts and hooks because there’s not a whole truckload of things that you ‘must’ master before you progress. Also, since boxing involves two contestants trying to knock each other out with fists, it is considered to be closer to emulating a self-defense scenario.
Boxing Vs Karate – What is Better for Self-Defense?
That depends on so many variables. Self-defense is more about being self-aware and using preventive techniques rather than engaging in combat every time.
But if it comes down to an unavoidable confrontation, there are a few things that can work in your favor.
If you are a karateka, the Dojo that you train in and the skills of your instructors are of utmost importance. Just like any other sport, you can find good instructors, absolute bad ones and there’s everything in between.
Some Dojos emphasize on physical fitness with full-contact or at least semi-contact sparring sessions that replicate high stress scenarios.
These is possibly the closest that you’ll come to a self-defense situation where you can be up against multiple armed opponents in a dark alley.
If you can find a Dojo that ticks both these boxes, we’d go with Karate over boxing purely because you learn more skills and techniques over boxing.
However, there’s an ancient theory that rather than learning a whole bunch of techniques half-heartedly, master a few of them to perfection.
If you can find a boxing school that whoops your ass and trains you for self-defense, go for it.
Who would win in a street fight? Professional Boxer Vs Professional Karate Fighter
Again, it depends on so many variables.
In a street fight, everything that you’ve learnt in a Dojo or a boxing school goes for a toss.
You are trying to hurt your opponent and they are trying to hurt you back.
If the Karateka is skilled in full contact and is able to land a debilitating first kick or punch, it puts them at an advantage. But if they aren’t used to full contact and rely heavily on kicks, then they may be in for a tough time against a boxer who can move fast and punch well.
Boxers try to minimize the distance between themselves and their opponents. They are trained for it.
And a skilled boxer who punches hard can do this in the blink of an eye and bring down a karateka.
But if they have poor defense and don’t move too fast, then it’s an even fight.
Who Would Win in a Professional Fight? Boxer or Karate Fighter
It’s one thing to be fighting on the street one on one with nobody scoring the fights. But it’s another thing to be fighting professionally one on one, a Karate master vs a Boxing professional. In a professional match that allows fighters to defend themselves and attack their opponents in anyway that they can the edge would go to the karate master. The Karate fighter would have more strategies of attack than the boxer would and this would allow the Karate master to defeat the boxing opponent. The boxer only has punching strikes master and that’s it. Only knowing how to punch somebody does not do you much good when you need to know how to take down an opponent that knows how to do a lot more than just punch you.